by Carrie Ryan
It doesn't often happen that a book elicits such a strong emotional response from me, yet I am unable to determine the simple fact of whether or not I like it or would recommend it. I read the first third of
The Forest of Hands and Teeth one day and was
raving about it.
Oh my goodness, this is so good, I am in love with it. I read almost the rest of it the following day and started
ranting about it.
I hate this book, I'm only going to finish it because I'm so close to the end and I want to know what happens, but I really, really don't like it. Then I finished it, and am somewhat undecided.
The setting is post-apocalyptic, in a small, fenced-off village that is protected from the outside forest and from the creatures that inhabit it: the Unconsecrated. (Or, as we would call them: zombies.)
The plot is intense, with excellent pacing. I agree with Sarah Miller's
review when she says, "Carrie Ryan created an entire society, plunged me into it, and parceled out its history and secrets bit by bit -- just enough to make me feel continually intrigued instead of lost or frustrated." The main character's internal struggles with loss and fear and love and wanting more than she can have were vivid and I empathized with and related to her. I liked her mental/emotional arc very much. The feel of the book reminded me a lot of the film
The Village, and whether or not that was intentional, it was something I liked about it.
What I didn't like was the sick feeling I had in my stomach every time I picked up the book. I felt this way in the beginning, too, but it didn't become overwhelming until about halfway through. The claustrophobia and aching I had just thinking of the characters' predicament was tremendous and awful and unlike anything I've ever felt while reading a book. The reality of their situation and of the terrible, horrific world they live in was something that almost ruined my entire reading experience. Despite all that is wrong in this world of
ours, despite the sin and corruption and sadness and fear, I believe it to be a beautiful place. A world of light and hope and trust and loveliness. If I didn't believe this, why would I want to stay alive? The world of
The Forest of Hands and Teeth drowned me with its darkness.
Call me sensitive if you will, but I don't think that's my problem here. I read a lot of books with heavy, hard topics and situations. Books that make me feel dark emotions. But never have I felt so consistently . . .
unhappy, while reading. The intense unhappiness lingered even when I wasn't reading it. Even with the small bits of hope and sacrifice and goodness that
were in the book, I couldn't reconcile the sense of despair that permeated me the entire time.
The story is fascinating. The characters are real and vivid and wonderful. The emotional complexities of the heroine are explored remarkably well. I might even want to read the companion novel,
The Dead-Tossed Waves, which comes out in a few months. In other words, there were things about this book that I really did enjoy. I'm just not sure it was worth the feelings of despair that came with it. Even when the characters weren't despairing,
I was. Constantly.
If you've read the book, please let me know your thoughts . . . I'm curious to hear if anyone else reacted to the book the way I did.